Loud, But Not Together: Why All This Music Advocacy Isn’t Adding Up

Music has more advocates than ever. What it doesn't have is a song we all sing together.

This spring, music fans did something no lobbyist, no hearing and no bill has managed to do in years. They stopped buying.

Major tours were scaled back or canceled across the country in 2026 as tickets went unsold. The industry even gave it a name, "blue dot fever," after the empty seats that show up as blue dots on ticketing maps. Average concert ticket prices have climbed more than 27% since 2019, and in 2025 total ticket sales fell even as industry revenue went up. Fans finally said enough. As the old saying goes, pigs get fed and hogs get slaughtered.

Nobody organized that. No coalition sent an action alert. Millions of people simply made the same choice at the same time, and the biggest companies in live music felt it.

That should tell us something about what we are capable of, and what we are missing.

A crowded stage

Music has never had more advocates. National trade groups. Venue associations. Songwriter and artist groups. City music offices, nighttime economy managers, commissions, task forces and coalitions. Every year brings more summits, more fly-ins and more reports.

And yet. Tickets cost more than ever. Songwriters are asking who really owns the organizations that pay them. Too many cities still have sound ordinances written as if music were a nuisance instead of an asset. With all this advocacy going on, why are things still so messed up?

Here is the honest answer. We sound like a band where everybody is soloing at the same time. Lots of talent. Lots of volume. Nobody keeping time, and nobody singing from the same song sheet.

This is not a knock on anyone. The people doing this work are some of the most dedicated in the business, and we are all in this band together. But a room full of great soloists is not a great band. Right now, we are making a lot of noise and not much music.

The other side keeps time

Big money does not solo. It plays the long game, stays on one message and pays professionals to keep the beat.

Take ticketing. In 2018, Live Nation spent about $240,000 lobbying in Washington. By 2023 it was spending $2.38 million a year, with 37 outside lobbyists, 25 of them former congressional staffers.

That money shows up in the fine print. The TICKET Act, the federal ticketing bill that passed the House in April 2025, sounds like reform. But the artist and venue organizations in the Fix the Tix coalition warn that, as written, it would legalize speculative “ghost” tickets and could override stronger consumer protections already on the books in some states. They have spent the past year pushing the Senate to fix it or stop it, while groups tied to the big resale platforms have lobbied for it. That is what happens when the money writes the first draft. Everyone else spends years playing defense.

It is not just ticketing. Wall Street and private equity money has moved into nearly every corner of our ecosystem. Three of the four major performing rights organizations, BMI, SESAC and Global Music Rights, now have private equity owners. Songwriters have been asking a fair question: when an owner needs a big return, who pays for it? Local music is starting to find out.

For now, the point is simple. The people with the money are organized. We are not.

Why we solo

It is not that music people can't work together. It is that our ecosystem is built in a way that pulls us apart.

You have heard of the K-shaped economy, where the top keeps climbing and the bottom keeps sliding. Music has a K-shaped ecosystem, and our advocacy has taken the same shape.

At the top of the K, national organizations work Capitol Hill on federal issues. GRAMMYS on the Hill turned 25 this year and put its weight behind three AI bills. Credit where it is due: three bills is real discipline. But those are top-of-the-K priorities.

At the bottom of the K, the working musician, the 200-capacity room and the songwriter who teaches lessons on the side are fighting different battles, mostly at City Hall. Sound rules. Permits. Rent. Late-night fees. Health care.

And every organization, at every level, answers to its own members, its own board and its own funders. Each one has its own list of priorities, and it is usually a long one. I tell every city I work with that if you need two hands to count your initiatives, you have too many. Our field has hundreds of groups and hundreds of agendas. Everybody is right about their issue. Nobody gets heard on all of them.

Performing rights organizations show how hard this gets. The PROs collect licensing fees on behalf of songwriters, and right now they are choking local live music. It is coming up in our work all over the country. The neighborhood bar or coffee shop that books a singer-songwriter on Thursday nights now needs a license from each of the major PROs, and there are more of them than ever. The National Restaurant Association says its members pay an average of about $4,500 a year for music licenses, in an industry that runs on profit margins of 3% to 5%. In a 2025 filing with the U.S. Copyright Office, the association said about one in five operators it surveyed had stopped live music or were thinking about it because of PRO fees and legal risk.

Our own census data tells the same story. In the music censuses we have run across the country, music performance licenses rank among the regulatory processes venues deal with most: 47% of venue and presenter respondents in Lawrence, 43% in Anchorage, 42% in Detroit and 41% in Northwest Arkansas. This past year we ran music censuses in six Kansas cities through Kansas Music Cities Together. In Wichita, Emporia, Manhattan and Topeka, more local creatives collect no performance royalties at all than use any single PRO. In Wichita, 53% collect none. In Emporia, venue owners told us licensing fees are one reason rooms book less live music. Put those together and the math gets hard to defend. A venue pays more because a local songwriter is on its stage, and across our census cities only about half of local creatives are registered with a PRO, so it is close to a coin flip whether that songwriter ever sees a dime of it.

Oregon is another snapshot. This year MusicOregon held a statewide listening tour, nine sessions in seven communities, and PRO enforcement came up as a serious and confusing problem in nearly every session where a venue operator was in the room. In The Dalles, an estimated 30 venues would like to host live music but don't, mostly because of PRO fees. A bar and grill in Grants Pass stopped booking music because of PRO pressure. A pub owner in Eugene plans to end live music after being told she faces $10,000 a year in PRO fees with no room to negotiate. And because every show now gets posted on Facebook and Instagram, venues that once went years before a collection agent found them are now being found in months.

And yet this is one of the hardest issues for our community to rally around, because our organizations serve different masters. Songwriters depend on those royalties. Venues and restaurants are the ones paying them. Both have a real case. In Oregon, the person who raised the issue in the Columbia River Gorge was a songwriter who belongs to a PRO. As that songwriter put it, "I don't think it's the intention of any artist who is a member of those organizations to stifle the roots of live music." Yet the groups that should be solving this together keep ending up on opposite sides of the table, and nothing moves. It does not have to stay that way, and the full PRO story deserves its own Field Notes, which is coming soon.

An office is a stage, not a crowd

Some cities have tried to fix this by creating a music office or a nighttime economy office. I believe in them. I spent years running one. But having an office does not mean everything gets fixed. An office gives music a stage at City Hall. It does not bring the crowd.

Orlando shows why. Its Downtown Development Board created one of the country's first Nighttime Economy Manager positions in 2017. Pull up its nighttime economy page today and you will find three programs: parklets, street ambassadors and the After Midnight Sales Permit. That permit, adopted in 2023, requires larger downtown bars and clubs that serve alcohol after midnight to get a special permit and help pay for police. One venue operator said the fees were costing him about $40,000 a month and had forced him to lay off more than 100 people. The city has since trimmed the fees, but the venues are still paying.

Here is the strange part. That same page encourages operators to get involved with industry groups, starting with the National Independent Venue Association. NIVA has asked the city to suspend those very fees. So the city's nighttime economy page recommends joining the group that is fighting one of the city's own nighttime economy programs. The office is there. The bill still landed on the venues.

Dallas is another reminder. The city hired a nighttime economy manager to work with its bars and venues, put him on leave last fall after he spoke to the media, and fired him this spring. The city says he misrepresented facts about his unit. He says he was fired for doing the job he was hired to do. While he was out, code officers started citing bars for charging a cover, and it took a public backlash from live music venues before the city formed a new nightlife task force.

That is not a criticism of the people in those jobs. It is a reminder of what the job can and can't do. An office can open the door. The community has to walk through it.

We know how to do this

Here is the good news. We have done it before, and not that long ago.

In the spring of 2020, every independent venue in America went dark overnight. Research at the time showed 90% of them would close for good without federal help. Venue owners who had spent years competing with each other formed the National Independent Venue Association almost overnight and agreed on one ask: Save Our Stages.

Then they brought the crowd. Fans sent more than two million letters to Congress. More than 1,200 artists signed on. The bill had a Republican and a Democratic sponsor in each chamber and ended up with 230 cosponsors. In December 2020 it became law as the $16 billion Shuttered Venue Operators Grant, the largest arts investment in U.S. history.

One ask. One message. Everybody singing it. It worked.

Then the crisis passed, and we went back to soloing. There is fresh proof that staying the course still works. When the federal antitrust case against Live Nation and Ticketmaster went to trial this March, the Justice Department settled one week in. A bipartisan coalition of 34 state attorneys general refused the deal and kept going. In April, a jury sided with the states on every antitrust claim, finding that Live Nation and Ticketmaster illegally maintained their monopoly. A separate trial on remedies comes next, and a breakup is still on the table. The states did not have the most money in that courtroom. They had the patience to see it through.

Money is loud. People vote.

This fall's midterms showed the same thing on a bigger stage. They were on track to be the most expensive in American history, with total spending projected near $12 billion. And in race after race, in both parties, money did not decide the outcome. In Minnesota's Democratic Senate primary, one campaign and its allies outspent the other $13.8 million to $3.3 million on ads, and the candidate who was outspent won by 20 points. In Louisiana's Republican Senate runoff, the incumbent outspent his challenger and lost 57 to 43.

The lesson for music is not about parties or candidates. It is that money is loud, but people vote. And music has more people than almost any industry in America. Fans. Musicians. Crew and sound engineers. Bartenders and door staff. Music teachers. The regulars at your local club. We rarely ask them to do anything but buy a ticket.

When we do ask, they show up, in cities of every size:

• New York City (2017): For 91 years, a cabaret law made it illegal for three or more people to dance in most bars without a special license. Activists had fought it since the late 1990s. In 2017 a new group, the Dance Liberation Network, launched a petition and packed town hall meetings in venues across Brooklyn. That fall the City Council voted 41 to 1 to repeal it.

• Chicago (2016): Cook County went after small clubs for back taxes, including more than $200,000 from a single venue, arguing that rock, rap and DJ sets were not "live cultural performances" and didn't qualify for the small venue exemption. Venues, artists and fans pushed back loudly. The county changed course and recognized DJ sets and live music as art forms.

• Salt Lake City (2025): The city proposed banning alcohol from 2 to 6 a.m. in all nonresidential spaces, a rule that would have hit social clubs and the late-night music scene. A club owner started a petition, and more than 10,000 people signed it. The council pulled the ordinance from its agenda. When it came back months later, it had been rewritten so it no longer singled out those businesses.

Every one of those wins came from people, not money. But notice that each one was a single fight in a single city, and most of them started only after the threat showed up. Imagine that energy pointed at the same few goals, in every city, at the same time.

What keeping time looks like

If you want to see disciplined advocacy, look across the pond at Music Venue Trust in the UK.

Since 2014 they have pushed essentially one big idea: £1 from every arena and stadium ticket should go back to the grassroots venues, artists and promoters who build the next generation of headliners. They said it over and over, year after year, with artists and fans behind them. The government got behind it. In 2026 the first £500,000 went out the door. PRS for Music, the UK's performing rights organization, even agreed not to take license fees out of that £1.

It is not finished. Plenty of big shows still have not signed on, so they keep pushing. That is the point. They picked their song, and they keep playing it.

We have the start of this here, too. Fix the Tix, a coalition of more than 30 music and live event organizations led by NIVA, wrote model ticketing legislation and took it state by state while Congress stalled. In 2025, Maine passed what the coalition called a nation-leading ticketing law. This year more than 100 ticketing bills have been introduced in statehouses across the country. That is what it looks like when a lot of organizations agree on one song.

Now imagine if we did that with a full set and brought the fans with us.

One song sheet, four songs

So here is my challenge to the music community.

For one year, what if every music organization in this country, from the national trade groups to the neighborhood venue association, sang from the same song sheet? Everyone keeps doing their own work. But these four songs become the ones we all sing together. Four is not a lot. Most of us need only one hand to count them.

1.Fair tickets. All-in pricing, guaranteed refunds, a cap on resale markups and a real ban on speculative “ghost” tickets. That means federal reform with teeth, not the TICKET Act as it is written today, and strong state laws where Congress won’t act. Every fan understands this one, and every fan can help.

2.Clear local rules. Sound, permit and late-night rules that musicians and venues can actually find, understand and follow, written with music at the table instead of after the fact. When we audit how cities communicate these rules, we find the same thing almost everywhere: most people want to comply, they just can't figure out what the rules are. Every city will write its own verse. The chorus is the same.

3.Money back to the grassroots. An American version of the UK's £1 contribution from every arena and stadium ticket to the local venues and artists who build tomorrow's headliners, plus property tax relief for independent venues, like Toronto's live music venue tax class.

4.Fair licensing for small rooms. Music licensing that charges for what is actually played and gets the money to the songwriters who played it. That means simpler, fairer rates for small and occasional venues, real transparency about where the money goes, and help for local songwriters to register and report their shows so they get paid. This is the one song that songwriters and venues can sing together.

Notice that the song sheet covers both halves of the K. One song is federal and state. One is local. One moves money from the top of the industry to the bottom. And one connects the people who write the songs to the rooms where they get played. Nobody has to give up their issue. We just agree on what we sing together.

Yes, licensing is the hardest song on the sheet. Our organizations serve different masters, and that is exactly why it belongs there. Remember the songwriter in Oregon: nobody who writes songs wants to stifle the roots of live music. If the people who write the songs and the people who own the stages can sing this one together, the rest of the set gets a lot easier.

And it only works if we bring the crowd. Here is what that could look like:

• Every organization puts the same four priorities on its website and in its newsletter.

• Once a month, everyone sends the same simple ask to members and fans: sign this, call this office, show up to this meeting.

• Artists say it from the stage. Venues put it on the screen before the show.

• At the end of the year, we report back together on what moved, and we pick the next set.

None of this requires a new organization, a new budget or anyone giving up their seat at the table. It requires agreement and patience.

The long game

Policy is a long road. The big money already knows that. It packs for the whole journey.

We can too. And we have something they will never be able to buy. This spring, without anyone asking, music fans sent the industry a message it could not ignore. In 2020, when we asked them with one voice, they sent Congress two million letters.

Imagine what they could do if we handed them a song sheet.

Next
Next

Hidden Rules, Honest Mistakes: How Cities Leave Music Guessing